What does it take to transfer understanding in the rational part of the brain, so that the emotional part ‘gets it’ too? The number of years I’ve spent in therapy, or support groups, is vast. Here’s a partial list of the therapy:
- 15 sessions with a court-ordered counselor when I was sixteen.
- 12 sessions with a PhD psychologist in college, after a suicidal gesture atop the campus bell tower.
- 180 sessions with another PhD psychologist, who called himself a behaviorlist.
- 20 sessions with a counselor in medical school, as I went through a divorce.
- 24 sessions with a Jungian analyst.
- 150 sessions with a psychiatrist during residency, who mostly had me talk about family-of-origin dynamics.
- 250 sessions with a psychiatric nurse who specialized in recovery from child abuse
- 20 sessions with a counselor who practiced sand tray therapy, among other things.
- 2 psychiatric hospitalizations, of 12 days and 8 days.
- 300 sessions with a psychiatrist who took me (again) through family-of-origin dynaymics
- 100 days or so in intensive outpatient treatment.
- 20 sessions or so with a social worker specializing in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) CBT and mindfulness.
- 12 sessions with a social worker specializing in Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT)–ongoing.
- Recent sessions with a social worker to deal with history of sexual abuse, and how damage from medication brings that up. (long story to be dealt with in another blog)
And here’s a partial list of the support groups:
- Support group of medical students weekly for 18 months in medical school, then occasionally for 2 years.
- Alcoholics Anonymous since 1987. Countless meetings.
- Alanon since 1988. Countless meetings.
- Adult Child of Alcoholics meetings weekly for one year while living in Manhattan. (These groups were often hard to take)
- Adult Survivor of Child Abuse meetings weekly for two years.
- An eighteen month intensive group therapy for child abuse survivors.
- Numerous meetings, sporadically attended, of other 12-step programs (e.g., debtors anonymous, sex and love addicts anonymous, etc.)
- Weekly meetings of a dual recovery group for 2 years ’06 to ’08.
- Weekly meetings for people with a history of problems with prescription drugs, ’06-’08.
Now, you would think that after all that I would not spin out because my blog-stats dropped. But I did. So how do I take all the knowledge that I really do have about codependence, abandonment issues, self-esteem, acceptance, etc, and make myself well? How come it is so easy to know something with my mind, but be completely clueless in my heart? Is there anyway to transfer the knowledge? Can I build some kind of high-speed data connection between the two parts of my brain that deal with these things? (Aside: Don’t you just hate brain/computer comparisons?)
The only answer I can find is to look for improvement (‘progress, not perfection’ is what they say in AA). Yes, I did crash and burn about the web statistics, but I pulled myself out of it pretty quickly. I was even able to see the humor in my response. That is much better than ever before. What’s more, I opened up about what was going on with me, reached out for help, and was rewarded by many kind messages from those who’ve been reading my posts. (And this was true even though I’ve only been doing this with any regularity for 3-4 weeks; a real testament to the kindness of those who read mental health blogs.)
Thus, I look for signs that my emotional skills today are more honed than yesterday. But I am still puzzled about why I’m so dense. Therapy ‘should’ help the emotions. The unconscious ‘ought’ to learn. But mine obviously did not. Or maybe it sometimes learned, but other times forgets. One way or the other, I find my theoretical understanding far surpasses my practical application of what I know about how to be healthy. Hence, I find it easier to give advice than to live in a state of emotional balance and spiritual connection. It would be easy to blog about all the stuff I’ve been told, and never mention that it only works for me half the time. But that would not be honest, or fair, or helpful to others or to me. So here I am, admitting that the simplest things still trip me up, even though I was fortunate enough to have good insurance, the resources to pay for what insurance would not, and to live in an area with a surfeit of recovery and therapy groups.
I’ll end by asking if anyone knows some tricks for taking cognitive understanding, and turning it into emotional maturity. I stand anxious to learn.
>> Share on Facebook>> Tweet

1
Wellness Writer at http://bipolarwellness.blogspot.com
Wow! I don’t have the answer to your question, but that is a lot of therapy and a ton of time spent in support groups. All I can say is that I was in therapy for ten years, and my therapist never diagnosed my depression even though it was a textbook case.
Over 40 years, I have seen seven psychologists and six psychiatrists, and met only one who has any insight.
And, while I’ve never joined a support group because it didn’t seem like a positive thing to me, I’ve experienced great support through my blog, and I’ve developed a wonderful virtual community.
I think the value of an online group is that it’s self-selective. The people who choose to read me are the ones I’d pick.
Susan
Posted at July 28, 2009 on 8:19pm.
2
Milo at http://likopoliom.blogspot.com
Sorry Will… I am of no good use today. barely dragging myself around for some reason. but i usually get to learn a lot from past similar situations (like i can recognize the similarities and i find it usually comforting). then i try to think what i can do differently this time to make things better. or what went so wrong the last time and try not to make the same mistake. it usually does the trick for me!
all the best, Milo
Posted at July 29, 2009 on 1:06am.
3
Will at http://willspirit.com
Yes, that is good advice. Thank you.
Posted at July 29, 2009 on 4:10am.
4
Will at http://willspirit.com
Despite the fact that I keep returning to it, my history in therapy has not been a pretty picture. One psychologist told me to switch to cocaine when I informed him about my heavy marijuana use. That same guy sent me on a blind date with another one of his clients, with the cheery prediction that we would “either get married or kill each other”. We did neither, but spent five years on the verge of both. Another encouraged my wife and me to sell our San Francisco house and move to the suburbs in the same year that Mandy’s father died, I was losing my career, a bunch of other stuff was happening, and we already weren’t getting along very well. One of my psychiatrists openly criticized many of my decisions, and my lifestyle, and not in a constructive or kind way. She also encouraged me to give up thoughts of future productivity, and she loaded me up with an incredible amount of medication. That I put up with all this is testament to my neediness and inability to set proper boundaries. But isn’t that why you go to therapists? To get help healing from such problems? So it does not surprise me that you have had poor luck with them.
(I should point out, in fairness, that some mental health professionals really have helped me. Especially recently. And usually in short term treatment.)
In the short time since the start of my blog, I have found this to be a very safe and supportive environment. It does seem like the ones who respond are the kind of people I would like to know in real life.
Posted at July 29, 2009 on 4:21am.
5
Milo at http://likopoliom.blogspot.com
Will, am I alright to link your blog to mine? sorry i forgot to ask. thanks for coming by to my blog place by the way… I am very grateful…
all the best, Milo
Posted at July 29, 2009 on 5:27am.
6
Wellness Writer at http://bipolarwellness.blogspot.com
Dear Will,
The advice you’ve received is among the worst I’ve ever heard. And, none of it is your fault. Yes, we go to doctors to get better. We assume that if they’re treating people like us, they have some insight. If we’re in a “bad place,” we assume they must know what what they’re talking about. If our judgment is impaired, we assume theirs isn’t.
You can only feel good that you didn’t sell your house, that you survived such horrible advice, and that perhaps your salvation will be in writing a book about the “abuses” so others can realize it’s not them…but the false healers they’ve seen.
Susan
Posted at July 29, 2009 on 7:57am.
7
Will at http://willspirit.com
Of course. Thank you.
Posted at July 29, 2009 on 8:04am.
8
Will at http://willspirit.com
Thank you, Susan.
Sadly, we did sell the house. That decision partly precipitated my breakdown in 2000. But like most things that start out bad, in the end good has come of it.
If I could discipline myself (more confidence would help, too) I would write such a book. The damage done to me by medications is another story worth telling and including in the saga; my mental health greatly suffered as a result of drugs that were supposed to help me (and which I am having terrible trouble quitting despite how I hate them). At least the blog is getting me to write something every day. The next step is to expand my work to include both the blog and a book. If I can.
Posted at July 29, 2009 on 8:13am.
9
werehorse at http://werehorse.blogspot.com
How to heal that separation between the head and the heart, how to truly understand the wisdom that the intellect appears to grasp so easily and actually make it part of you so it informs and influences your actions, emotions and choices from within rather than the rational mind trying to impose it on the rest of you, has been so far, and still is, one of my longest journeys.
I don’t know what the answer is, except that I believe it is to do with healing those divisions within ourselves at a deep level and not just about acquiring further superficial understanding or developing greater discipline or increased domination by the apparently rational mind. Letting go of the battle.
Thank you for coming by my blog and commenting, because if you hadn’t I wouldn’t have found yours and it is very interesting!
WH x
Posted at July 31, 2009 on 9:36pm.
10
Will at http://willspirit.com
Thank you for the compliment. I enjoyed your site as well. As to your suggestion, it brings to mind why I named the site WillSpirit. Aside from ‘Will’ being my first name, I saw it as a project in bringing the ‘will’, or rational/conscious mind, into harmony with the ‘spirit’, the unconscious/intuitive mind (the heart?) So it is interesting that you suggest using less of what might be called ‘willpower’, and instead relying on deeper parts to help out. Sounds like the right answer to me.
Posted at July 31, 2009 on 10:03pm.
11
freda at http://YourWebsite
Banish ‘should’ and ‘ought’ from the dictionary!
Posted at August 1, 2009 on 10:27am.
12
jss at http://YourWebsite
I would second what Freda just said. Man if you can do that than you’re cured I’d say.
I think a lot about this very topic. Compared to you I’m just a therapy babe, about a year and a half and boy the head is so far ahead of the heart it ain’t even funny. I sometimes wonder if ‘get better’ is a realistic goal although in fairness I suppose that getting better is relative. Better compared to what I wonder. The guy next to me in the grocery store line? Sad to say but I might already be better compared him. Funny thing is ‘getting better’ wasn’t even on my agenda when I first walked into my therapist’s office. All I wanted was a change of career. Who knew that an alcoholic parent could wreak such havoc – without me even knowing it. I figured on a couple of months and I was out of there. I was so grossly out of touch with myself it’s actually kind of sad.
I sometimes wonder if all we ever get at this point is the knowledge and we have to do with that what we can. When I hear and read about people who after years of therapy and medication still struggle with depression and what not it makes you wonder if getting better is possible. But you know I’ve realized that my goal is to know myself better and try to tap into some of my potential as a human being. Therapy is an appropriate place to do this – with the right therapist that is. I have been fortunate in that arena. As for my emotional state – a year and a half later I still struggle mightily with expression of emotion. I can talk about anybody and anything, anywhere no problem, but as soon as that conversation comes around to me I’m stuttering and stammering and generally looking (and feeling) like a fool. Honestly sometimes I feel like the way I am is permanently burned into my soul and any change is always going to be a conscious act of will. Will that ever change? I don’t know. I try like hell though every week and maybe someday…
Posted at January 7, 2010 on 3:15pm.
13
Will at http://willspirit.com
jss–
Not having looked at this post for awhile, I must say it sounds dismal. So many years of therapy, so little obvious progress… Granted, between a terminally depressed mother, sadistic stepmother, alcoholic/narcissistic father, and mentally ill sister, my family hardly left me in good shape to face life. So I probably needed the help, and maybe things would have been worse without all the mental health work.
Learning about the self is never a bad thing. Too many people remain oblivious to their personalities and weaknesses. Whether self-knowledge translates into greater happiness is an unanswered question. The only therapies that have ever been ‘proven’ to reduce depression and anxiety are those based on cognitive techniques.
The real question is, as you suggest, what do we mean by getting ‘better’? If someone grows up abused and deprived, and then faces huge adult losses, it might not be realistic to expect great happiness. Acceptance, on the other hand, can always be achieved. And with acceptance comes contentment. I think peace in the heart is a realistic goal. Freedom from sorrow may not be. This is not to say we can’t learn to be less depressed, less anxious, etc., but we have been misled by our culture to view ‘happiness’ as the ultimate purpose of living. A person who fails to achieve frequent gratification is not a failure. A person who never grows, on the other hand…
In my opinion, if there is a reason for our presence on this planet, it is to gain wisdom, not pleasure. Everyone who overcomes selfishness, bitterness, and escapism will attain a measure of maturity and wisdom. That’s the only guarantee in life. All the therapy in the world won’t assure happiness. But it does help with understanding, and that is why I still return to it now and then.
–Will
Posted at January 7, 2010 on 9:11pm.