WillSpirit!

Where Will meets Spirit
∞ Love, Clarity, Balance, Peace, & Bliss ∞

A science, mental health and spirituality blog written by a physician.








  • Red_Exclamation_DotDisclaimer
    • Dear Visitors:
      Although I trained and practiced as a physician, my background does not include formal instruction in psychiatry beyond basic medical education. This journal presents ideas about treatment philosophy, but must not be considered therapeutic advice. Abrupt changes in one's psychiatric medications can trigger profound cognitive, emotional, and physical symptoms, including suicidal thoughts and actions. Consequently, pharmaceutical agents should not be increased or decreased without supervision by a mental health clinician.

    • ON THE OTHER HAND, your brain belongs to you, and your opinion counts. If you decide that changing your medication regimen will serve your best interest, then I believe your providers have an obligation to help you try to achieve your goals. I want everyone to be educated about their options, and do what will be most helpful for themselves. No one should feel pushed around by dogmatic and/or limited viewpoints, whether those of psychiatrists, anti-psychiatry advocates, or myself.


We ARE All This


December is poetry month here at WillSpirit. Please forgive the digression as I take a needed break from essay writing. Just scroll back to November to get to the real substance.

The problem
Behind every problem
That plagues our humanity
Is our common sense
Of ourselves as solid and important,
Separate and special,
Whether as individuals, religions, nations, races,
Or a species.
We are NOT.
We are NOT separate from what we see.
We are NOT better than beetles,
Or smarter than snakes,
Or nobler than nuts,
Because we ARE beetles, snakes, and nuts.
Even as we think these thoughts as selves,
We ARE life in all its sacred and ordinary glory.
The web of ecology doesn’t surround us,
It is what we ARE as individuals, races, and species.
So terrifying to watch a loved one make bad choices
And self-destruct.
So much worse to watch humanity
Cut off an arm to mine coal from a mountain,
Or rip off its skin to raise cattle in the tropics,
Or incinerate its members to protect oil in the desert,
Or taint its blood and oceans with poisons.
The problem
Isn’t that we make bad decisions about how to manage the world.
It’s that we think there’s a separate world to manage.
We ARE the world of life. We ARE.

>> Share on Facebook
>>





Self Importance?

Look closely. See the tiny hominids in the snow?

This afternoon my wife and I went canoeing on a reservoir here in the Sierra Foothills. Manmade lakes aren’t our first choice for boating, but today’s scenery was surprisingly lovely. The weather was warm, very nearly hot, but on the water the temperature was pleasant. The sage colored hills shone around us, covered as they were by scrub brush and scattered digger pines. A light breeze helped stir the air, and we saw more jumping fish and waterfowl than expected. A nice day.

But of course I’m not blogging about this trip just because it was fun. This same body of water is one we drive past frequently. Viewing it while cruising by at sixty miles per hour, it never struck me as a very big lake. How different it seemed on a canoe! It took ages to get across a narrow point in the reservoir, and the journey felt a bit nerve-wracking, since we ordinarily stay close to shore in our tippy watercraft. Half-way across I realized with slight apprehension that we were all alone on this vast body of water, and would not be noticed if we capsized.

The surrounding foothills rolling away from us on all sides emphasized how small we were relative to the landscape. This is a good lesson for the ego. It is bracing to look around once in awhile and get a feeling for the body’s scale relative to the earth’s. Ecological crises, networked communications, and global financial markets have persuaded us we live on a small planet, and this is indeed an important truth. But any one human remains ridiculously tiny compared to a mountain, not to mention a continent, the globe, or a galaxy.

In our immature phases, we think about our selves excessively. How am I doing relative to others? Am I attractive enough? Successful enough? Wealthy enough? Popular enough? With so much thought about ME, it is easy to get fooled into thinking my self important.

But let’s consider our actual situation. Imagine looking down from a jetliner at cruising altitude. Get a sense of the human scale against the backdrop of the planetary. This perspective makes it harder to feel as necessary as we do in our most narcissistic moments.

I’m fond of pointing out that to say the name of every person on earth, at the rate of one per second, would take two hundred years. A similar dwarfing occurs if we look at the length of a human life relative to the age of the earth. If the earth’s age were compressed to a single year, our lives would be lived entirely in the final half-second.

We are tiny beings of no great consequence beyond the small number of others who happen to have bonded with us. I say this not in a negative way, however, but to encourage us all to look at what matters more, what truly endures. Aside from life itself, the human family has lasted long enough to count even in this vast universe. And as members of it, we count too. Not as individuals, but as components of the larger whole.

So if our importance comes from association with the entire collective of people on earth, we should give thought to how we can benefit the human family. We should focus on the common good, and not our insistent but unimportant hungers. This is the path to sanity and even more, to realization. Yes, this is the path to Grace.

>> Share on Facebook
>>





Self Love and the Biology of Self

Heart&Lungs

In recent months, a plan has formed to wean myself away from the comforting bosom of therapy. A post I wrote six months ago detailed the huge amount of psychotherapy and group work I’ve completed. Some of it enlightened me, some of it led me astray, and much if it had little effect at all.

Just as I prepare to swear off therapy forever, fate has brought me a counselor who truly helps me. Partly it’s a good personality match; partly the ACT philosophy he adheres to works well for me (as discussed on this site many times); and partly I’m finally ready for a fundamental change.

Not that I’m close to ‘cured’, or even ‘stable’, but something inside seems to be shifting. One good example came in my most recent session. It was the first in almost two months, and had been arranged as an urgent appointment because of severe depression.

The biggest reason for my suffering, being perfectly blunt, has always been self-hatred. My upbringing beat it into me. My earliest memories are of my parents’ bitter divorce, during which it became obvious that my dad despised the role of father. In most of my memories of my mother, she lies in bed nearly catatonic with depression. She couldn’t offer much love. After that came her death, a probable suicide; a six-year-old takes a mother’s dying as a personal rejection. Within weeks I began living with my bitter father and sadistic stepmother. The woman humiliated and tormented me with cold, calculated efficiency. (Those interested can read about her in a memoir fragment .) My dad, narcissistic and obsessed by his work, was also an alcoholic. In short, my childhood taught me to feel unwanted, unworthy, despised, tormented, and abandoned.

Sadly, I still feel all those things, only now the hatred comes from my own heart. This is probably the most sensitive secret I’ve revealed on a site riddled with self-disclosure. It is the root of the worst of my problems. It keeps me at arms length from life and loved ones, because I never believe I deserve either.

My counselor and I have talked about this self-loathing many times. On this last visit, he instructed me to hold out my hand. “Can you love your hand?” he asked.

To my surprise, the answer was, “yes”; loving a body part seemed easy. The full significance did not sink in right away.

My adoration of biology, which goes back to my earliest days gardening and fishing with my grandfather, makes admiration of anything alive no problem at all. People, redwood trees, mice, and all other living things enthrall me. I’m even fascinated by mosquitoes. I have an inborn reverence for everything that lives. But until recently, I had never honored myself for my own biology.

For some time, I’ve practiced a meditation where I simultaneously feel and visualize my internal physiology. I sit on my meditation cushion and breathe, all the time imagining the air seeping into the tiniest passages and pockets of my lung. I think of the oxygen turning my blood corpuscles bright red. While concentrating on the sensation of my heartbeat, I form a mental picture of my heart pumping this freshened blood to the rest of my body.

Even though I regularly settle into my biological nature, it had never occurred to me to love myself as a living organism. I was too busy hating my personality, my decisions, and my sins. All my hatred has been directed at me. Which raises the question, “what am I?” Am I a disembodied mind? Can I really separate what goes on in my brain from the body that holds it? The obvious answer is “no”.

After my appointment with the therapist, I did my usual ‘biological’ meditation, only this time I honored the miracle of my animal form, and allowed reverence to surface. At the same time, I held the thought that I am my body. After all, the sensation of a mind separate from the physical self is an illusion, or even a delusion. It’s the ego’s way of isolating and empowering itself. The truth is that body and self are one. In accessing my respect for my own life processes, I discovered a bit of love for myself. It feels wonderful.

Not long ago, I thought my recent spiritual growth had banished inner darkness. Soon after, I found myself fueling a depression with my habitual self-contempt. The old obsessions, regrets, and fears returned with full force. Having learned from that relapse, and despite this insight about my value as a living animal, I will be shocked if the horrible despair does not soon resurface. On the other hand, perhaps I will remember to feel reverence toward my body, and the biological mind it supports. Perhaps I will feel a trickle of love for myself.

>> Share on Facebook
>>





‘Through a glass, darkly’

rose tinted glasses on a dog

Sometime back I promised a post about how one’s attitude changes with drugs. When I quit Cymbalta almost a month ago, I quickly lost my confidence, started to feel tired and discouraged, and decided life did not have much value. I fear that without my strong connection, devotion, and commitment to Mandy I would have succumbed at last to the suicidal tendencies that have dogged me since my first major depression at age twenty. Yet not long before things had looked pretty rosy to me.

At present I am coping with some medication-induced injuries that will never leave me, even though I’ve quit the drugs that caused the damage. I find the destruction visited upon my body demoralizing and infuriating. But before stopping the Cymbalta, it seemed like my grip on the situation had improved, and I had hope that with a little time and meditation my distress would abate and I would settle into a more-or-less calm acceptance. Not long after my final dose of that drug (I continue to take several others), the problem started looming large again. I felt, once more, like my life had been destroyed. Given that my passion for breathing (and all the other essential components of human life) has always been lukewarm, suicide started to look like a logical and acceptable solution. How much grief, defeat, and loss can one person take?

As I’ve implied, my agreement with myself and Mandy is that I will stay around for our relationship. So although I had a well-worked out plan for my demise, I never set a time frame, and just sat out the foul emotional weather. In just the past day or so, I have started to feel more like I can continue to live without merely gritting my teeth and waiting for natural death. Life has begun to look worthwhile again. Mandy and I have more frequent affectionate moments, I smile more often, and I feel like my energy has returned. Today we happen to be enveloped in smoke, due to a supposed ‘controlled burn’ that escaped its lines and is now raging in Yosemite. Every few hours the wind shifts to carry a thick cloud of particulate haze into our region. If we did not have so much air pollution, I’d be outside catching up on all the chores I neglected as I fought my way through this withdrawal. It feels good to recover the desire to be productive. I hypothesize that my brain is building more serotonin and norepinephrine receptors to compensatefor the reduced levels of those transmitters that followed stopping Cymbalta. (See this discussion about what is probably going on.)

My optimism would be greater if this had not already happened once. About two weeks after cessation there came a previous time of relief from the whirlwind, but it only lasted five or six days. So I will not be surprised if the curtain descends again. But right now I am feeling better, and I won’t spoil it by predicting another setback. This is how I ended my post back at the time of the last break from despair: “What I’ve written so far is the introduction to my real topic: the relationship between the chemicals that traverse my brain and the ‘person’ that the organ produces.”

For a number of reason I never got back on-subject. Today I am going to try to tackle, in a small way, the relation between chemical changes in our brains and the people we think we are.

In my opinion, it comes down to something like different vantage points. I wrote during the last storm break about how my little house in the hills would be invisible to a passenger in one of the airliners that regularly stretch contrails above me. I live my drama down here in the trees, yet those in the aluminum tubes soaring overhead have no clue about my problems and discouragement. They just don’t see my world of concerns. When I am medicated, it is like I am flying in the stratosphere. I observe my anxieties glide beneath me, but they look tiny and far away. Sometimes they get obscured by the pretty scenery, and I can almost forget they exist. But when I stop the drugs, I land flat on my belly on the August-baked earth, and gasp for full breaths in the smoky air. The pharmaceutical agents become the proverbial ‘rose-colored glasses’, that make a dim world look bright.

If they worked as well as I describe, I’d have to ask why one should fight the way I do to end my dependence on the medications. But if you look through pink-tinted lenses long enough, you no longer see the pink. Your mind adjusts and everything starts looking the way it did before. So then you are no longer jetting through the upper atmosphere close to the speed of sound, and instead end up bouncing along at ground level in a dilapidated truck. What’s more, even though the chemicals no longer help as much, the side effects continue. That is why I stopped Cymbalta. It helped my mood a bit, but the benefit diminished until it no longer seemed worth the heavy cost in adverse reactions (primarily anorgasmia). So I stopped taking my daily green pills, and have been fighting to regain my footing ever since.

If my entire opinion about whether to live or die hinges on a chemical called duloxetine marinating my brain, the question becomes, who am I? The suicidal man who feels life has dealt so many injuries it no longer warrants engagement? That is to say, am I ‘really’ this troubled person who emerges upon cessation of the drugs? Or am I instead the (kind of) bubbly soul that can discover benefits even in raw wounds and festering infections? Am I ‘in fact’ the wry middle-aged guy who emerges when the drugs (occasionally) work perfectly well?

Or am I both? Or neither?

At least I now recognize that my feelings change. It used to be hard for me to see that my attitudes shift. If the world felt awful, I believed in an unshakeable way that my feelings at that moment accurately summed up the nature of life as it had always been. On the flip side, if things looked cheery, I had a hard time remembering how it felt to be depressed. After years of gyrating feelings and world-views, I now recognize that tectonic shifts have repeatedly rocked my inner environment. My ability to predict eventual good feelings even when I am mired in deep depression has improved. I have recollection when I feel rotten that life once seemed fun, and vice versa.

As that sort of memory consolidates, I start to appreciate that my feelings are transient little things that have no direct relationship to outside reality. They are my internal filters, and not firmly connected to either the external scenery or my actual ‘self’. The same person (me) and the same life (mine) can look ashen through one set of spectacles, and sunny-yellow through another. I am the person behind the glasses, or even further back: behind the eyes. Possibly the real me looks through yet another screen: the brain. Some believe that our true selves have no material biology, but exist as ethereal spirits. I don’t go quite that far, but there is no question that somewhere separate from all the opinions, all the filters, all the moods and feelings, sits a person who is protected from the storms, and watches with a wise and tolerant eye as all the hurricanes and earthquakes and volcanoes thunder over the landscape. I’ve mentioned Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) before, and I am touching here on ACT’s core assumption.

I am not the earth’s tremors, or the volcano’s blast. I am not the wind or the sun or the rain. I am the ‘self’ that observes all the changes, all the weather, all the thoughts and feelings. But this is so easy to forget. It is as if, while watching a movie, I confused the events on the screen for things in real life. If I think that somehow my identity is that of a scared and lonely man, hemorrhaging and forlorn, I am overlooking the fact that at other times, with different chemicals in my blood, I feel like ‘someone’ entirely different.

It could be that I am nothing more than a memory stream. A dynamic album of photographs that keeps adding page after page after page. My identity cannot be pinned down to any particular image, not even the most recent ones. Instead, to get any sense at all of ‘me’ as a stable and defined entity, you have to look at the entire book as a unit.

By changing my drug regimen I am not creating a different person. I am just turning the page, putting in new pictures taken through different lenses. What I think and feel today is just an addition to my identity, not the summation of it.

Does this make any sense at all to others? I know these ideas are not mine alone, and no doubt writers more eloquent than I have stated something like the same point of view with greater clarity and logical support. But this is what I meant to bring up two weeks ago, during my previous respite from the Cymbalta-withdrawal nightmare that has been my ‘reality’ since August first. I am aware of some texts I need to read that touch on similar streams of thought. When I get more information, a wider perspective, and time to digest, I will return to this subject of self and how it relates to the turbulent currents of mood, opinion, biochemistry, and experience.

mothdrawing
For now, I am glad of the break from the pain. It feels good to expand again, and fill my wings with blood the way a newly metamorphosed moth pumps itself up before taking flight into the moonlit sky. For now, at least, I can nourish myself again, and savor the nectar of daily life.

(Click here to link to a nice video showing a moth feeding on nectar.)

>> Share on Facebook
>>





Archives